Convergent Journey

A cuppa tea and a camera

Posts from the ‘Bureaucracy’ category

UK Border Control: Bests and Worsts, Mostly Worsts

Two stories about the UK border agency. First, the worst airport in London. Second, the immigration officer who not so subtly hinted I should leave the country.

1. THE WORST AIRPORT IN LONDON

Especially with the Olympics coming up and tourists already swarming in London now that it’s spring, there’s been a lot of talk about how awful the delays are getting through immigration at Heathrow. Reacting to that, there are the “What delay?” articles. As well as that great tool of lazy reporting, crowdsourcing.

I’ve had two visitors come in through Heathrow in the past week, and both of them said they breezed right through. So maybe Heathrow’s not so bad after all. Flying into Gatwick has never caused any problems, and Luton is by far the easiest: quick, painless and a straight shot to the bus. (By the way, for service from Luton, I love easyBus. If you arrive earlier or later than expected, they’ll put you on the next bus free of charge.)

Without a doubt, the absolute worst immigration control is at Stansted Airport.  Given all the heat that Heathrow’s been getting, a few media outlets have been analyzing Stansted too. This from the BBC:

A spokesman for the airport, owned by BAA, said: “The majority of passengers arriving at Stansted pass through border controls quickly and securely. However, at peak times, and similar to many other UK airports, immigration queues can be unacceptably long.”

Ha! Well, truth be told, getting through the EU/UK citizens line seems easy enough. But there is no airport in London quite like Stansted for discrimination against non-EU/UK passport holders.

Even when there were only eight people in front of me with two desks open in the “All Passports” line, I waited for an hour. No exaggeration. The people in front of me were Turkish passport holders who seemed like a group of family and friends, and each person who went to the desk had to talk to the immigration officer, wait while the officer called for help or verification, then sit off to the side until they were summoned elsewhere. Each took about ten minutes, and the officers kept getting up to leave the desk in between! Drive. me. crazy.

The second time, there were about fifteen people in front of me, with only one desk open. A group of Chinese students who were travelling together ran into the same situation: Desk. Wait. Call up. Sit to the side. Get summoned. Officer leaves with them. Students here on visa have to match up their fingerprints, and the system wasn’t retrieving any of theirs.

Stansted Airport. Worst.
Photo source: The Telegraph

Problems: (1) Too few officers. (2) Broken systems. And (3) inefficient design. The wheelchair access lane should not go through the All Passports line. No discrimination here against handicapped access, but for efficiency’s sake, when there are eight desks open on the EU/UK passports side, it would make more sense for everyone involved to have the handicapped access line be serviced there instead. (Wanting to be careful about how I described this, I took particular note of whether the people being served through the handicapped access lane were EU/UK citizens or not. And indeed, all handicapped access passengers are served through the “All Passports” side, including EU/UK citizens.)

As the line behind me grew longer—up to thirty or more—and still ten more to go in front of me, I could hear people sigh audibly every time our lone immigration officer had another holdup, or another handicapped passenger took precedence. And the crazy thing is, just when you get excited that a second immigration officer has come down to open another desk, once that desk is open, the other officer leaves!

Enough griping. How about something to be thankful for?

Well, with an American passport, when I do finally make it to the immigration desk, I answer two questions, match my fingerprints, and I’m outta there in thirty seconds. God bless America!

2. “PLEASE LEAVE NOW,” IN SO MANY WORDS

So much for the stereotype that Brits are polite.

Returning from Paris by Eurostar, I thought, on a 7.30am train there shouldn’t be bottlenecking at immigration (which you have to pass through as you leave Paris). But bottlenecking there was.

An American family—a girl studying abroad in London and her parents— was in front of me. The parents were flying out of Heathrow later that day, while the girl would stay on in London.

“When are you leaving the UK?” the officer asked.
“Today,” the parents replied.
“Where are your boarding passes?”
“We haven’t printed them out yet.”
“I need to see your boarding pass.”
“But we haven’t printed them—here, I have it on my phone.”
“No sir, we cannot accept electronic passes.”
“But our flight leaves today, we’re going to pick up the e-tickets—”
“I’m sorry, I need to see your boarding pass.”

The officer may as well have been a robot. How much more obvious could the circumstances be? After a few more minutes of fumbling, they, too, were summoned for further questioning. How long will you be in the UK? What time is your flight? And you, how long will you be studying in the UK? What are you studying? Where? 

When it was my turn, the immigration officer asked me:

“Where are you studying?”
“LSE.”
“Have you booked your flight back to the States?”

Excuse me? This was in early April, and my visa is valid through September. Time to pack those bags—apparently I’m not wanted here!

*Shakes fist*

EPILOGUE

I did make it onto my train with barely three minutes to spare, and the family scrambled on only moments before the doors closed. I know this because they happened to be in the same train car as I was, and they talked loudly about what had happened for forty-five minutes. On a 7.30am train. What sympathy I had for them vanished after the first fifteen minutes. Not a single other person was talking; most were sleeping. Fulfilling the stereotype that Americans are loud.

About these ads
8 Comments

Things I Don’t Like about London

I’m actually cool now with driving on the wrong side of the road. But I really wanna know, what exactly ARE those squiggly lines for anyway? (Answer: Highway Code Rule #191, here.)

Because there are some, and it’s time to get real.

My blog may seem a bit Pollyanna at times, as I try to keep things positive and choose my words wisely. This is because (a) no one likes a whiner and (b) I’m wary of posting anything online that might haunt me later. Not that the masses are reading my blog or I’m anyone important (yet), but you never know. The Internet never forgets. (Try Googling Anthony Weiner, for example.)

But the truth is, I’ve now been here long enough that the little things are starting to get to me. So here goes.

1. The Food

It never fails to meet my low expectations.

(With a few exceptions: Indian food, good. Fish and chips, flaky-fresh. Soups, hearty. Yogurt, delicious. Bourbon creams, indulgent. Tea and scones, habit-forming. But everything else I could do without.)

2. The Customer Is Probably Wrong

British customer service, true to its reputation, can be pretty atrocious. The theory is that it’s because the British keep calm and carry on a little too well. If no one complains, no improvements are made to the system. As an American, though, I’m used to the “have it your way” approach: you may have to navigate an intentionally cryptic automated menu to get to a real person, but stay on the line long enough and fight hard enough and, if all else fails, invoke the manager, and you will ultimately get your way.

Not so, in London. Bang on a brick wall long enough, and you end up with bloody knuckles.

Case in point: I was running late but stopped by PAUL for a quick breakfast. I gave the cashier £20 for a breakfast that cost £2.95. She gave me back £2.05, thinking I’d given her a £5 note. I explained the discrepancy, and she apologized and asked me to wait for the manager so she could open the till.

The manager came in a huff, took the entire till out, grabbed a calculator, and proceeded to count all the money in the till against the day’s revenues thus far. I was aghast. Is this really happening right now? Is this normal? What the heck is going on?

After ten minutes counting the money, the manager told me that there was no discrepancy according to his calculations. He said in a skeptical/accusatory tone, “We don’t have CCTV. I don’t know how much you gave her.” By then I was so irritated at being forced to wait, at the insinuation that I was lying just to scam off 15 quid, basically at being treated like a cheat when the error was the employee’s. It literally left a bad taste in my mouth, so I left the food I had purchased untouched and walked out. But I immediately doubled back because I figured, it’s YOUR mistake and I don’t want my money in your till, supporting your shoddy business that treats its customers so poorly. So I insisted on getting my money back. He refused.

I probably shouldn’t have let it get to me quite so much, but it just, really, rankled me. The irony was that I was running late to church, and the incident put me in such a bad mood that I didn’t hear a word of the sermon because I was mentally phrasing an angry email to the corporate customer service department the whole time. The email was, I hope, equal parts eloquent and angry, and I received a surprisingly nice response that apologized, explained it was company policy to do so in the event of a dispute (which I still think is crazy)*, and offered a refund. I suppose all’s well that ends well, but it was nonetheless the strangest and most degrading feeling to be accused of lying, in so many words. Perhaps it riled me up as much as it did because it came at a time when I was starting to feel a bit homesick.

*Note: PAUL is a French company, so perhaps that accounts for their whack policy. But the problem was in the execution, not the policy itself. It would have been different if the manager had said at the outset, I’m sorry, but this is company policy and this is what I have to do when a customer disputes a transaction. No such explanation was given; when it comes to customer service, it’s like employees are paid to be as unhelpful and unyielding as possible. Chicken or the egg: Maybe this explains why tipping is less common here. Or is the service poor because there’s no incentive to do better? 

3. Is This What Homesickness Feels Like?

I’ve never experienced homesickness before, but it makes sense that this, if any, would be the first time. I’ve spent months and weeks abroad at a time, and not in English-speaking countries. But the longest I’ve ever been away was three months, so if there ever was a time for me to find out what homesickness is, it would be now.

It’s a combination of missing the company of people who know me well, those to whom you don’t have to explain anything; missing the ease of striking up a new friendship when you have a lot in common with the person you’ve just met; missing the familiarity of knowing how a system works, even if it’s faulty, because at least you know what to expect and how to navigate the situation. (Take, for example, the experience above.)

Of course, it’s not like the UK is all that different from the US, especially if you’re going from New York to London. We speak the same language, we watch the same TV and movies, we live in a busy, cosmopolitan city. And I have been fortunate to meet some great friends here… but still, deep, and especially comfortable, friendships just take time to build up. I understand that, and I didn’t come expecting to feel right at home right away. And actually, the transition in the first three months was so much smoother than I expected, what with finding a great church community right away and meeting a great group of girls in my hall.

But by month five, I started to see that there are differences after all. In particular…

4. Let’s Talk about Race

This is admittedly an observation based on limited experience and intuition, but British people seem to be uncomfortable talking about race or ethnicity. I still don’t fully understand what “multiculturalism” is in the British sense, but I don’t think it lends itself to meaningful discussion about race. Instead it seems to brush it under the rug, like saying, “Of course there’s difference,” without discussing what it is. Almost a patronizing “That’s nice,” but claiming to appreciate difference is an easy out for actually learning about it. Or, I don’t know, maybe people think it would be impolite to ask?

Whenever I crack jokes about being Asian, for example, I get an uncomfortable chuckle in response on a good day. The best shot one guy once gave was to say that he knows about Korean food: “You eat dogs.” He thought it was funny. I rolled my eyes.

I’m not sure if I’m being overly sensitive, and I hesitate to write about this without a more solid sense of what’s awry. But because the topic seldom comes up, all I have to go on is my intuition, and the best I’ve been able to come up with is that people avoid the topic. Which tautologically puts me right back where I started.

5. Speaking of Patronizing

I’ve heard a number of remarks and/or conversations defending the benefits of colonialism.

I have no comment on this; don’t even know where to begin. Flabbergasted.

So that’s my moment of honesty. I’m almost exactly midway through my time in London, and I have a lot to look forward to. My challenge to myself for the next five and a half months is to make the most of every opportunity; to keep building friendships, instead of pulling away because I’m mentally preparing to move back; to seek to learn as much as I can, and be as much of a blessing as I can, for as long as I’m here; and to maintain a sense of adventure!

In the next entry, we’ll be back on a fun wavelength: more visitors! Madrid & Segovia! Maybe a daytrip to Bath! Good times ahead, y’all.

*To my British readers, I mean no offense, and I’m certainly open to discussion if you take issue with any of the above. Enlighten me!

7 Comments

LSE: 3, SIPA: 0

These days, when I talk to friends back at SIPA, I try to reel in my LSE/London enthusiasm, because on the flip side it could be taken as, “SIPA sucks and I don’t miss you at all!”

Which of course is not the case, at least not the latter part.

So in a nutshell, here’s what I think about SIPA: It’s possible to have a good experience, but the institution doesn’t make it easy for you. It’s a matter of finding a good group of people, hunting down the right professors and shoving your way past the crowds into their office hours. There are just too many students; the feeling that you are little more than a dollar sign to the administration is prevalent, and, I would argue, not successfully handled from the top.

The advantage of being in a smaller program at LSE (approx 80 per class, to SIPA’s 450) is that the atmosphere is less bureaucratic. The administrators know your names and actually hear what you’re saying. Case in point:

1. A small request, a big whiteboard

About three weeks ago, my capstone group was meeting in one of the MPA rooms, and we told Michelle (one of the MPA coordinators) that it would be nice to have a whiteboard in there.

“Yes, that’s a great idea!” she enthused.

We met in the same room yesterday, and at one point in the meeting, a group member pointed behind me and said, “Let’s put it up on the whiteboard.” I turned around and, to my shock and awe, our suggestion had actually been acted upon immediately!

A small thing? Sure. But would this ever happen at SIPA? I mean, at SIPA we still write on chalkboards. (And good ol’ Emmanuele with the  hand-shaped chalk streaks everywhere… hahaha. It really is the people that make SIPA worthwhile.)

2. Professionalism on so many levels

Some successful internal public relations and goodwill generation from the MPA administration:

2nd year MPA students are warmly invited to come along and have a professional profile photo taken on Tuesday 1st November. Electronic copies of your chosen photo will be provided for your use in CVs and online profiles and it is also intended that these will be used collectively in raising the profile of both individual students and the MPA programme overall.

I was seriously impressed by this—not just the fact that they held a photo session, but also that they sold it so successfully. It’s not that I doubt their motives for doing it (as though they’re doing it just to placate us), but rather that the intent “we have your interests at heart” was conveyed so subtly and successfully—indeed, in such a way as to suggest sincerity.

SIPA administration, take note!

(Sorry, SIPA friends! Wish you were here.)

Related Posts:
LSE: 1, SIPA: 0
Wild Goose Chase

4 Comments

Efficient Bureaucracy? No way.

Alright, I’m impressed. The first batch of my postcard project went out on Monday afternoon, and arrived in NYC mailboxes three days later!

Photo courtesy of L in NY

(I blurred out the addy, so don’t even think of stalking my friend.)

I suppose if the speed of your mail service is tied reputationally to the crown, you’ve gotta be quick. The impressive postal service here brings the tally to UK/LSE: 2, US/SIPA: 0. (See previous.)

Not that I’m actually counting. There are great things about NYC, too, and today in particular I was missing it more than I have yet. But that’s for another day, another post.

Just a reminder that you can get a postcard by following the instructions here!

2 Comments

Free Healthcare, with a Jab

Got your seasonal jab yet?

Every year, I forgo the flu shot, cuz I just don’t like shots. I’m not sure calling it a “jab” makes me feel much better about it… but I probably really should get one this year.

Is healthcare really free here?

Back in NYC, a few friends used to get together every so often for a “documentary club,” where we’d watch a documentary together, then discuss the issues raised in the film over dinner. Some really interesting documentaries, and insightful discussions.

One of the movies we watched was “Sicko,” a Michael Moore film that examines the US health care system. He compares it to other countries’ health care, including the UK system, NHS:

After the film concluded, my friends all looked my way and told me to go find out if it’s true.

I went to the NHS clinic on my campus today. The truth that I don’t like to talk about too often is that I have constant pain from a chronic condition, and it’s worsened to the point of feeling debilitated on some days since I’ve gotten here. It’s been hard. So I wanted to go, get checked up, and see if the NHS might be able to help me out where, indeed, the US system failed—my insurance stopped covering my treatment about a year and a half ago, at which point I simply went without.

Health care is indeed free. But it didn’t come without a pointed jab from the doctor. She told me she would refer me to a specialist, and I asked her about costs and copays.

“You won’t have to pay,” she said. “It’s paid for by taxpaying individuals who are paying for the insurance coverage… freeloader.”

Haha, just kidding, she stopped before “freeloader.” But really, how many times can you say pay in one sentence?

Thank you, NHS. To keep things fair and square, maybe you should convince your prime minister to chill out about border control, and give me a job here, so I can pay you back some taxes for helping me out this year?

Leave a comment